Harmony (Wa) in Japanese Society: Tradition, Practice, and Contemporary Challenges
Rogaleva Ekaterina
Department of Socio-Cultural Activities and Performing Arts, Institute of Culture and Arts, Moscow City University
Moscow, Russia
Abstract: This article explores the foundational role of harmony as a core value in Japanese society, tracing its historical origins and examining its manifestations in social structure, cultural practices, and daily life. Harmony in Japan emerges from a unique synthesis of Shinto, Buddhism, and Confucianism values, first codified by Prince Shotoku in the 6th century and enduring as a guiding principle of social organization. The paper examines how harmony is maintained through strict social hierarchies, collective obligations, and ritualized etiquette, which minimize conflict and promote group cohesion. Everyday customs – from workplace dynamics and family roles to seasonal festivals, cuisine, and aesthetics – are shown to reinforce a life in tune with nature and community. The analysis also addresses modern challenges to harmony, particularly the post-World War II influx of Western individualism and competitive ethos, which many Japanese observers argue have eroded the traditional “spirit of wa”. Even so, a renewed nostalgia and hope for revitalizing harmony-based values are rising in Japan. The article concludes that harmony remains vital for Japan’s social fabric and suggests that re-embracing this classical virtue could guide Japan through its current cultural value crisis.
Keywords: harmony; Japanese culture; collectivism; Shinto; modernity in art; interpretation; co-creation.
Introduction
When envisioning Japanese society, outsiders often imagine a well-ordered system whose members know and unfailingly follow its rules. A familiar image arises of Japanese individuals building successful careers, serving as model family members, honoring parents and ancestors, and proceeding dutifully through life. Many Western observers are astonished at how Japan manages to remain faithful to the traditions and values of its past amid a rapidly changing world. What underpins the vitality and prosperity of this system? It is well known that Japanese society is relatively closed, hierarchical, and collectivist. Such a society must possess a system of values capable of protecting its social order from foreign influences that might otherwise reshape the Japanese mindset. Indeed, Japanese consciousness shows a remarkable ability to selectively adopt foreign cultural products while preserving its traditional way of life, a duality of conservatism and openness. This paradox is made possible by an inherently Japanese value known as “wa” (「和 ), meaning harmony. How is this value of harmony expressed in Japanese society?
Historical Foundations of Wa: Shinto, Buddhism, and Confucianism.
The deep entrenchment of harmony in the Japanese psyche was profoundly influenced by an organic blending of Shintoism, Buddhism, and Confucianism over the centuries. In A.D. 604, the regent Prince Shotoku Taishi enshrined the ideal of harmony as a fundamental value in Japan’s earliest quasi-constitution. Prince Shotoku is traditionally credited with the saying: “Buddhism is the branches on the tree of Shinto, and Confucianism the leaves on those branches.” This metaphor can be interpreted to mean that, building on the robust foundation of Shinto in the Japanese worldview, Buddhism took root, and only then was society prepared to absorb Confucian values. Shotoku’s first article famously decreed: “Wa should be valued and quarrels avoided… When superiors are in harmony with each other, and inferiors are friendly, then affairs are discussed quietly, and the right view of matters prevails”. In other words, harmony was elevated as the supreme guiding principle of governance and social interaction.
Shinto, Japan’s indigenous religion, had no strict dogma; its essence was a belief that every phenomenon in nature. Mountains, rivers, plants, animals, the sun, and rain contain a divine spirit or kami. Harmony, in Shinto teaching, meant living in accord with the surrounding natural world. Buddhism, introduced from the continent in the 6th century, initially met resistance but was embraced by leaders like Shotoku, who saw its teachings as complementary to Shinto. Buddhism added a spiritual-philosophical dimension, emphasizing compassion and the impermanence of life, which reinforced an inner harmony and acceptance of change. Confucianism, arriving later via Chinese influence, further shaped the notion of harmony to mean living in accord with society. Confucian ethics, with its stress on filial piety, social hierarchy, and moral duty, gave harmony new expression as orderly social relations, loyalty, and ritual propriety. Thus, the concept of wa expanded beyond reverence for nature and ancestors to include structured social harmony, virtue of duty, and formalized etiquette. As one scholar observes, Confucian values deeply informed Japanese ethics, especially in business contexts, by bolstering group cohesion and consensus-driven decision making [Kulneva 2012].
Harmony through Social Structure and Hierarchy
One of the most visible manifestations of harmony in Japan is the highly structured and hierarchical organization of its society. Every person has a clearly defined place with specific duties and rights. By honorably and diligently fulfilling one’s responsibilities in that position, an individual helps society function smoothly and constructively, and in return gains a sense of security and belonging. Adherence to hierarchy in Japan is rooted in a deeply ingrained mental model of the nation as a family, wherein the younger defer to elders and trust their decisions, and the elders take responsibility for the younger. This paternalistic social model dates to the Tokugawa shogunate: in the early 17th century, Shogun Iyasu Tokugawa brought peace to a country weary of civil strife by rigorously assigning each class – samurai, peasants, artisans, merchants - its proper place along with corresponding rights and duties. Under this Tokugawa order, so long as one faithfully performed one’s work, even those of low status could expect protection of their rights. Consequently, people came to regard the ability to occupy one’s proper place as a sign of personal dignity and strength of character. Later, during the Meiji era and beyond, the loyalty and diligence of Japanese subjects were increasingly oriented toward reverence for the emperor as the “father” of the nation. This attitude, civic devotion combined with filial piety toward authority, persists in helping Japanese value their own labor and respect the work of others.
Today, the same family model of social harmony is evident in Japanese corporate life. Companies often function like extended families, with employees viewing themselves as devoted children of the organizational household. Workers unite to do everything possible for the good of the company, mirroring the devotion of children to their parents. The understanding is that if all members of the “family” work toward its prosperity, the company will thrive, and so each person’s diligent work is a contribution to the common harmony and success. In turn, traditional Japanese companies have reciprocated with strong paternalistic support, exemplified by the system of lifetime employment and generous social benefits, taking care of employees often until retirement. This mutual commitment binds the group together and fosters harmony: everyone knows their role and future within the organization. Such clarity brings peace of mind to Japanese employees, for whom uncertainty and chaos are deeply unsettling. The overall result is a work culture where collective harmony is prized over individual ambition. As anthropologist Ruth Benedict observed, Japanese society instills in individuals a drive to “measure up” to their social role and obligations, equating professional honor with personal honor [Benedict 2004]. A contentment in fulfilling one’s predefined role has long served the cause of harmony in Japan, in stark contrast to many Western societies.
The Ethic of Duty and Collective Responsibility
Harmony in interpersonal relations is also safeguarded by a distinctly Japanese ethic of duty and obligation, often conceptualized as giri (義理, “duty” or “social obligation”). From a young age, Japanese people are taught to carefully follow social rules and meet the expectations associated with their roles, and they expect the same of others. There are traditional norms governing how to speak to whom, how deeply to bow, what sort of gift to give, and how it must be reciprocated. Such standardization of behavior acts as a social lubricant, ensuring that in daily and business interactions, one seldom encounters the unexpected. In Japan, an exemplary deed is often met not with surprise but with the phrase, “As was expected of you,” underscoring the predictability of proper conduct.
This predictability is possible because the Japanese weigh social relations on the scale of reciprocal obligations. They are respectful and deferential to parents’ will, considerate and polite with peers, dutiful and reliable at work, all propelled by an internalized sense of obligation. Fulfilling one’s obligations is not viewed as subservience, but as arising from an awareness of deep connections to others and genuine gratitude for others’ contributions in one’s life. Whether repaying a parent (a duty called oya-kōkō, filial piety) for the gift of upbringing or honoring a teacher for imparting knowledge, the readiness to repay these debts of kindness reflects a natural generosity of spirit. Only a truly magnanimous person, it is thought, can live a lifetime in gratitude and respect toward someone who once helped them.
Crucially, this generosity does not negate the famous Japanese reserve in expressing feelings or making promises. A Japanese person understands not to impose on others in a way that would make them feel excessively indebted, just as one must avoid making rash promises, because a promise immediately becomes giri, a debt of honor that one is morally bound to fulfill. To break such an obligation would be to lose face and honor. As Benedict detailed in her study of Japanese culture, the failure to discharge one’s giri leads to intense shame, while success in fulfilling obligations brings honor in the eyes of society [Benedict 2004]. Hence, one should not be surprised if, upon offering a seat to a Japanese stranger on a train, you receive puzzled looks - the stranger may be perplexed why you would want to impose a debt on a person you don’t know. The ability to appropriately carry out one’s giri guarantees a person acceptance by, or expulsion from, the immediate society (seken) of which they are a part. Each Japanese belongs simultaneously to multiple seken, one’s family, school class, company, neighborhood, etc., and behavior is governed by a powerful moral accountability to those present communities. In any setting, whether on a train, in a shop, or at the office, a Japanese individual will behave in whatever way is necessary to prevent conflict and avoid clashes of interest in that context. Causing trouble (迷惑 meiwaku) for others is a cardinal sin to be avoided at all costs.
In moments of crisis, this strong sense of collective responsibility and social harmony becomes strikingly visible. Even during the catastrophic 2011 Tohoku earthquake and tsunami, which devastated northeastern Japan, social order largely prevailed. In the disaster’s aftermath, observers worldwide were astonished by the absence of chaos: survivors across affected towns queued calmly for food and aid, and neighbors spontaneously organized volunteer help squads, feeling a mutual responsibility to maintain order and help the vulnerable. Foreign journalists reported on the “near-total absence of looting and crime” in the quake zones and noted that Japanese citizens, even after losing everything, continued to help one another with courage and discipline. This resilience was not because hardship was any less severe, but because Japanese culture, reinforced by social institutions, had long taught that everyone’s behavior is essential to keeping society together. In these dire conditions, people still largely followed the ethos of wa, avoiding panic or selfishness. The strong protected the weak, and order was preserved in the face of chaos. Such examples illustrate how deeply the ethic of harmony and duty is ingrained in Japan’s social fabric.
A Japanese person will go to great lengths to preserve their reputation and honor, because they feel an obligation to their good name and the groups it represents. This “name” (名誉 meiyo, or social honor) is multifaceted. It includes one’s professional reputation, family name, and standing in any community. The Japanese are famously punctual and conscientious, partly because they regard their professional honor as equivalent to personal dignity. For example, when Greco-Roman wrestler Kenichiro Fumita won a silver medal at the Tokyo 2020 Olympics, he broke down in tears and publicly apologized for what he called a “shameful result.” Fumita felt he had let down his team, coaches, supporters, and thus his country, by not achieving gold. His reaction might seem extreme, but many Japanese athletes similarly apologized even for silver or bronze finishes, reflecting an ingrained instinct to meet collective expectations and not bring dishonor to those they represent. One might think that this pressure to meet social expectations is highest for public figures, but it extends throughout society. Consider the case of a humble Takoyaki (octopus dumpling) stand owner in Osaka in 2021: when a customer complained of finding a hair in her food, the proprietor immediately shaved his head bald as an act of contrition. In Japan, shaving one’s head is an old-school way to show a sincere apology for a grave mistake. The owner not only did this but also went to the customer’s home to apologize in person. Such an extreme gesture demonstrates how seriously Japanese individuals take the duty to perform their roles properly, even in a small business, and how urgently they act to restore harmony and honor when it is disrupted. In sum, the Japanese strive to fully live up to their roles and statuses, which directly define their social persona. This conscientious fulfillment of one’s place in society is a pillar of harmony: everyone doing what they ought to do, so that interpersonal relations remain smooth and honor is preserved.
The contrast with Western society is striking. In many Western cultures, individuals are encouraged to constantly strive for personal advancement, chasing ever-higher material success or social status. This mindset yields innovation and progress, but often at the cost of perpetual dissatisfaction - one is rarely content with one’s current position and thus not truly at peace with oneself or the world. In Japan’s traditional value system, by contrast, there is virtue in contentment and balance. Ambition is tempered by the idea that exceeding or deviating from one’s proper place can disrupt harmony. A person who continuously refuses to accept their role, endlessly seeking more, is seen as lacking wa and disturbing the collective equilibrium. While not inherently anti-ambitious, the culture of wa teaches that true happiness comes from knowing one’s place and contributing to the whole, rather than individual competition. This difference reflects a deeper divergence in values: the primacy of spiritual and social fulfillment over material gain.
Harmony in Daily Life, Culture, and Aesthetics
It is evident that Japan’s commitment to harmony rests on an underlying prioritization of the spiritual over the material. Yet, as Shinto teaches, spiritual values reflect the material, physical world - meaning harmony also manifests in the concrete routines of Japanese life. A close look at Japanese lifestyles reveals that the laws of harmony are observed in all things, from personal cleanliness to cultural pursuits. For example, the simple habit of daily bathing is about more than hygiene; it is seen as a way to purify the body and relax the mind, keeping oneself “clean” in both a physical and spiritual sense. Likewise, various disciplining practices – from morning calisthenics and meditation to the precise routines of martial arts or tea ceremony – are aimed at cultivating a clean spirit and clear intentions. Traditional Japanese cuisine (和食 washoku) is renowned for its balanced, harmonious combination of ingredients and its respect for natural flavors and seasons. Meals are prepared and presented with a mindfulness that reflects harmony between taste, nutrition, and aesthetics. Notably, the healthfulness of washoku is often credited with contributing to Japanese longevity, illustrating how living in harmony with nature’s offerings (eating seasonal and locally sourced foods) directly benefits individual well-being.
A prominent cultural ideal in Japan is to live in harmony with the seasons. The Japanese hold that each season carries a unique energy and lessons, so by adjusting one’s activities and mindset to the time of year, one stays in tune with the larger rhythms of nature. This can mean enjoying specific seasonal foods at their peak, performing seasonal traditions, and even subtly changing home decor or clothing motifs to suit the season. According to Japanese folk wisdom, practicing the appropriate customs for each season fills people with harmony and allows them to absorb the energy (ki) of that time of year. Here, Buddhist influence echoes Shinto’s nature reverence: Buddhism emphasizes that seasons (and all things) are impermanent and fleeting. Therefore, every moment is precious because it holds an unrepeatable experience, a teaching captured in the expression ichi-go ichi-e (一期一会, “one moment - one opportunity”). At the same time, since the cycle of seasons is eternal in its recurrence, one should live in the flow of time, moving from one stage of life to the next without undue anxiety or regret. Embracing this view fosters inner harmony: one celebrates the bloom of spring cherry blossoms even knowing they will fall in days, and one endures winter’s barrenness knowing spring will come again. As the seasons change inevitably, so too must people accept change and find continuity in change. This philosophy not only pervades Japanese poetry and visual art, but also everyday life. For instance, families eat chestnuts and mushrooms in autumn because those foods symbolize the fall harvest, and they welcome the New Year by deep-cleaning and purifying the home in winter, believing it sweeps away spiritual impurities of the past year. Throughout the year, there are seasonal festivals (matsuri) and observances that reinforce communal harmony and respect for nature’s cycles.
In summer, during Obon (the Festival of the Dead), Japanese people return to their hometowns to honor their ancestors’ spirits, keeping harmony with the familial and spiritual realm. Autumn is the time for contemplation of maple leaves, chrysanthemums, and the moon (through customs like momijigari - maple viewing, chrysanthemum exhibitions, and tsukimi - moon-viewing nights). People will appreciate these symbols both in reality (viewing the colored leaves or harvest moon outdoors) and in art (reading poems, visiting art exhibits featuring autumnal themes), thereby aligning their hearts with the season’s beauty and transience. Winter brings the year’s end, when it is customary to thoroughly clean and sometimes renovate the house, a practice called ōsōji, to welcome the new year with a fresh, harmonious start. Finally, spring is celebrated by delighting in the awakening of nature, most famously through hanami (flower viewing) under blooming sakura (cherry blossom) trees, which epitomize the poignantly brief beauty of life.
The attentiveness to seasonal harmony also extends to living spaces and aesthetics. Traditional Japanese homes are designed to blend with nature and encourage contemplation. A key feature is the engawa (縁側) - a narrow veranda or porch surrounding the house, which serves as a transition between indoors and outdoors. Sitting on the engawa, one can admire the garden and feel at one with the environment, whether enjoying a cool breeze in summer or the moonlight during an autumn tsukimi. Gardens themselves are crafted as microcosms of the natural world, often incorporating rocks, water, and plants to mirror a larger landscape in miniature. Many homes include a carefully tended garden or at least potted plants to invite nature’s harmony into daily life. Inside the home, the tokonoma (床の間) alcove in the main room is reserved for displaying a scroll of calligraphy or painting and perhaps a seasonal flower arrangement. This simple alcove acts as a spiritual and aesthetic focus of the room, often an altar for ancestor veneration or a place to display art that reflects the season or an important sentiment. Every object in a well-designed Japanese room has its proper place and function; clutter is avoided so that space itself can convey a sense of balance. The result is an environment where, much like in a Zen garden, the emptiness and simplicity are intentional and meaningful. Each thing, by being in the right place, contributes to an overall sense of order and calm. This harmonious ordering of space is not only practical but spiritual. It is meant to mirror an orderly mind and a harmonious society at large.
Japanese art forms similarly emphasize subtlety, suggestion, and balance as reflections of harmony. In poetry, especially haiku and waka, feelings are expressed in an indirect and refined manner. There is a saying in Japanese aesthetics that to speak too openly of one’s emotions is crude, for overt expression cheapens the feelings and disrupts the harmony of communication. Instead, the highest artistry lies in suggestion, allowing the reader or viewer to intuit the depth of emotion or meaning that is merely hinted at. This aligns with the aesthetic principle of yūgen (幽玄), often translated as a “mysterious profundity” or subtle grace. Yūgen has been described as “a beauty that hints at more than what is said”, the highest ideal in classical Japanese poetry. In a few lines of verse, a great poet evokes a universe of unspoken feeling, a technique that requires the reader’s active imagination to complete the picture. By leaving things unsaid, Japanese arts invite a quiet participation and maintain a sense of harmony between expression and silence. Whether in the sparse brushstrokes of an ink painting or the pregnant pauses of a Noh theater performance, restraint and understatement are employed to evoke a profound emotional response without ever breaking the harmonious surface with blunt explicitness. In essence, Japanese culture has cultivated an “art of the unsaid”, believing that what remains implicit can be more powerful and more harmonious than what is overtly declared.
Contemporary Challenges to Harmony
Despite its enduring legacy, the spirit of wa in modern Japan faces undeniable challenges. In recent decades, especially since the end of World War II, many in Japan feel that society has drifted away from its traditional harmony-centric values. The postwar occupation and rapid Westernization introduced capitalist competition, individualism, and liberal social models that, over time, have subtly reshaped aspects of Japanese life. Japanese commentators lament that these Western influences, capitalist free-market ideals, and an emphasis on personal freedom have sown disintegration by pitting the strong against the weak, undermining the old ethos where the strong were duty-bound to protect the weak. As journalist Michael Hoffman observed, “Western culture pulls people apart, pits the strong against the weak. Japan’s culture draws people together. Wa prevails. That’s a Japanese national trait or was,” he adds, until recent reforms accelerated inequality. In particular, the early 2000s saw neoliberal economic policies that prioritized competition and efficiency, breaking down some of the social protections that companies and communities once offered. The result has been a widening gap between winners and losers, with the rich getting richer and the poor growing more numerous. This growing socio-economic stratification is often cited as evidence of waning harmony, since it suggests that societal unity is giving way to a more fragmented, competitive order.
Indeed, in contemporary Japan, one finds more situations where decisions in relationships or business are driven by self-interest and profit rather than mutual obligation or honor. The communal solidarity that once characterized neighborhoods and companies has been weakened in places by an ethos of individual gain. Young generations, exposed to global media, may place less automatic importance on traditional duties like caring for aging parents or lifelong loyalty to one employer. Social issues such as increasing elder loneliness, declining birth rates, and the phenomenon of social recluses (hikikomori) are often interpreted as symptoms of a fraying communal fabric. The COVID-19 pandemic, too, tested social harmony: while compliance and cooperation were high, economic pressures revealed rifts as businesses struggled and inequality became more visible.
Yet, against these troubling trends, there is also a countercurrent of hope and revival for wa in Japan. Nostalgia for the “good old days” of Shōwa-era stability - perceived as times of greater social harmony and community spirit has grown. Many Japanese are revaluing aspects of their culture that promote harmony, from re-engaging in local festivals and traditional arts to championing concepts like “Japan’s spiritual culture” (yamato-damashii) as something worth preserving in the modern era. There is a burgeoning interest in minimalist lifestyle and Zen-inspired well-being practices among youth, reflecting a desire to escape the chaos of hyper-competitive life and find inner harmony. Some leaders and intellectuals call for a return to certain Confucian or communitarian values to address social ills, for instance, by encouraging companies to re-embrace employee welfare or communities to support young families. In the media and pop culture, themes of friendship, teamwork, and belonging remain perennially popular, suggesting that the ideal of harmony still resonates deeply with the Japanese public. The persistence of orderly social behavior even under duress, such as the disciplined mask-wearing and courtesy shown during the recent pandemic, indicates that the cultural training in wa is far from lost.
Crucially, the bridges to Japan’s past are not yet burned. The Japanese can still rediscover a path to societal happiness by tapping into the wisdom stored in their own history. Modern Japan has reinvented itself before: at the end of the Tokugawa period in the 19th century, facing internal crisis and external threat, Japan’s leaders turned to the ancient concept of harmony (along with reverence for the Emperor) to rally the nation, leading to the Meiji Restoration, a successful blend of old spirit and new technology that transformed the country. It may be time again for a kind of cultural restoration, one that rejuvenates the principle of harmony on a new footing suited to the 21st century. As one commentator in 2016 put it, the task ahead is to balance Western-inspired innovation with Japan’s traditional wa, so that economic progress does not come at the expense of social cohesion. This could involve policies that mitigate extreme competition, corporate practices that value employees and consumers as partners, and educational emphasis on ethics and community belonging alongside individual achievement.
Conclusion
Harmony (wa) has been and remains a cornerstone of Japanese society. On a relatively small archipelago nation with a dense population and having experienced long periods of isolation, the Japanese developed a highly reflexive and tradition-oriented mentality, one deeply shaped by the authority of ancestors and the lessons of history. It is no coincidence that when Japan confronted the tumult of modernity at the end of the Edo era, its leaders sought solutions by reaching back to ancient wisdom and reasserting traditional values (such as harmony and loyalty) to guide the nation’s transformation. In the present day, Japan finds itself in a period of soul-searching, a mild crisis of values brought on by deviations from the once-dominant principle of harmony. The evidence of social strain, whether in the form of economic disparities, changing family structures, or youth disaffection, has led many to question how much of Japan’s “spirit of wa” has been lost in the pursuit of Western-style progress.
Nonetheless, the essence of wa is far from extinguished. The very fact that there is widespread nostalgia and discussion about harmony indicates that Japanese society is self-aware and values this ideal. Perhaps Japan stands at the cusp of another great renewal. By looking to the past and rediscovering the enduring merit in its traditional values, Japanese society may find a way to recalibrate its course. A renewed commitment to harmony adapted to contemporary realities but rooted in the timeless wisdom of wa could very well become the key to Japan’s cultural rejuvenation in the new era. In an increasingly fragmented world, the Japanese example of harmony, if successfully revitalized, might even serve as an inspiration beyond its borders for how balance, respect, and collective good can be harmonized with modernization. After all, the pursuit of harmony has always been Japan’s path to social stability and, arguably, to happiness. As the adage goes, “Wa wo motte tōtoshi to nasu,” harmony is to be valued as the highest good, and it may once again light Japan’s way forward.
References
1. Arakawa, D. “Shintoism and Traditional Values of the Japanese.” Russia and the Asia-Pacific Region 1: 63–74, 2005.
2. Baseel, Casey. “Japanese cook shaves head in apology after customer complaint.” Japan Today, June 1, 2021.
3. Benedict, Ruth. Chrysanthemum and the Sword: Models of Japanese Culture. Moscow: ROSSPEN, 2004.
4. Evans, C. D. Alexander. “What Keeps the Japanese People Together.” Dissent Magazine (online), May 11, 2011.
5. Hoffman, Michael. “Western Culture and the End of Japanese ‘Harmony’.” The Japan Times, December 17, 2016.
6. Ignatovich, A. N. Buddhism in Japan: An Essay on Early History. Moscow: Nauka, 1988.
7. Kulneva, P. V. “Influence of Confucian Values on Japanese Business Ethics.” Japan. Yearbook 41: 123–140, 2012.
8. Meshcheryakov, A. The Book of Japanese Customs. Moscow: Natalis, 2006.
9. Rich, Motoko. “Second Best in the World, but Still Saying Sorry.” The New York Times, August 5, 2021.